The Impact of the Japanese Tragedy
The earthquake in Japan will undoubtedly have a negative impact on Japan’s economic growth in the near term. It will also disrupt operations of many Japanese companies (and even some non-Japanese companies who do business in Japan). Reflecting these concerns, Japan’s stock market has declined over 17% since Friday, so much of the short-term impact may already be priced into equities.
Longer term, we believe the earthquake is unlikely to have a material impact on Japan’s economic and stock-market performance, though it is too early to say what the economic cost of this tragedy will be. Japan’s last major earthquake, Kobe in 1995, was estimated to cost more than $110 billion, which the country was able to absorb. Today, Japan is a $5 trillion economy so even if this disaster proves more costly, the country should be able to absorb the rebuilding expense. Longer term, as history has shown, countries do recover from such disasters, often with economies stimulated by rebuilding damaged infrastructure. The risk is that Japan’s already high public debt (over 2x GDP) and large fiscal deficit (of nearly 7% GDP) constrain its ability to fund necessary expenditures.
We do not expect the Japan tragedy on its own to have a material short- or long-term impact to global economic or earnings growth, although as we write this the nuclear reactor problem is a wild card with the potential for serious consequences at least shorter term. According to the Bank Credit Analyst, an independent global investment research firm, Japan has contributed about 2% to 3% to global economic growth over the past five years on average, so it seems unlikely that an economic slowdown in Japan could bring about a global recession. That said, the global economy is already fighting what we think are more material headwinds, such as deleveraging from developed countries, higher oil and food prices, monetary tightening from emerging markets, etc., and it is possible that Japan could tip it in the negative direction.
Impact to Our Portfolios
Japan makes up about 15% of a typical international equity index that includes emerging markets. Factoring the different equity weightings across our model portfolios, and taking the index weighting as a starting point, Japan’s weighting in our portfolios ranges from less than 1% to 3%. Moreover, our Japanese exposure is well diversified across many companies. Of course, global equity markets have also declined in the aftermath of the Japan disaster, but not anywhere near the magnitude of the drop in the Japanese stock market.
We asked several of our international bond and equity managers how the Japanese companies they own will be impacted by this natural disaster. In general, the response we have gotten is that there will be no material impact to their investment thesis or their estimate of the business’ long-term intrinsic value because of the earthquake.
The indirect impact to our portfolios, however, could be more material. As noted above, it is possible that Japan’s tragedy tips the world into a slowdown or a recession when combined with many other macroeconomic headwinds we see.
Despite the recent market decline in Japan, we do not see Japanese equities as a tactical investment opportunity at this time. Both the Japanese economy and its stock market, we believe, have to contend with significant fundamental issues in addition to the problems created by the earthquake and as such we see more downside risks there. Japan continues to fight deflationary forces because of anemic consumer demand, and the current tragedy could depress consumer sentiment further. Also, from a purchasing power parity perspective, the yen looks overvalued and may be a headwind to returns for a dollar-based investor.
We will continue to monitor the events in Japan closely and take appropriate portfolio actions based on the risks and opportunities we see. Because we do not believe that Japan’s tragedy on its own makes much of an impact on our assessment of global earnings power and, as a result, valuations, if global equity markets decline further, we may use that as an opportunity to add to equity risk.
Michael Vandenburg, CFP®